Champions One-Day Cup: A Grand Show or Just Another Distraction Amidst Pakistan’s Cricket Crisis?

As Pakistan cricket reels from a humiliating 2-0 home Test series whitewash against Bangladesh, the Champions One Day Cup comes across as an oddly timed spectacle. While the national team struggles on the international front with no substantial changes or clear strategies in place, this domestic tournament feels more like a sideshow rather than a meaningful step towards reform. In fact, many within the cricketing circles are calling the whole Champions Tournament series — the One Day Cup, followed by the Champions T20 Cup and First-Class Tournament — a vanity project. It seems PCB Chairman Mohsin Naqvi is more interested in leaving behind a “legacy” rather than addressing the real, pressing issues plaguing Pakistan cricket. This initiative, aimed at putting his name in the annals of Pakistan cricket history, risks being remembered more for its superficial gloss than for any substantive contributions to the game.

The 2024 Champions One-Day Cup is set to bring yet another round of thrilling cricket action to Faisalabad, with Pakistan’s top domestic cricketers ready to compete in this apparently much-needed tournament. With free entry and matches from September 12 to 22, the fans—those still invested in the system—will have the chance to witness Pakistan’s future hopefuls and same-old seasoned players duke it out in the 50-over format. The tournament, we are told, holds extra significance as it will allegedly set the tone for Pakistan’s upcoming international fixtures. However, amidst a backdrop of recent failures, including a 2-0 home series defeat, the tournament seems to be a grand spectacle from Chairman Mohsin Naqvi, rather than a genuine solution. As skepticism looms, here’s what the captains have to say as they gear up for this highly anticipated event.

Saud Shakeel’s Dolphins: Eyeing a Winning Start or Just Following the Script?

Pakistan’s Test vice-captain Saud Shakeel leads the Dolphins with the obligatory high expectations, as they take on Shadab Khan’s Panthers on September 14. The Dolphins, supposedly balanced with a mix of experience and youth, might sound promising, but we’ve heard this narrative before. Under the guidance of Sarfaraz Ahmed—another revered figure in Pakistan cricket—expectations are being managed more than raised.

Shakeel has dutifully echoed the familiar refrain, saying the tournament provides players a chance to impress selectors. Yet, how many players have really propelled themselves to international glory from domestic tournaments that feel more like a ticking of boxes? Sarfaraz’s involvement, though touted as a “massive boost,” feels more like lip service to the idea of leadership, as the team gears up for the routine set of matches against the Panthers (14 Sep), Wolves (17 Sep ), Stallions (19 Sep ), and Lions (22 Sep).

Dolphins squad (to be trimmed to 15 on 10 September): Saud Shakeel (captain, Karachi), Aftab Ibrahim (Karachi), Asif Ali (Faisalabad), Awais Ali (Gujranwala), Faheem Ashraf (Kasur), Kashif Ali (Rawalpindi), Mir Hamza (Karachi), Mohammad Huraira (Sialkot), Mohammad Abbas Afridi (Peshawar), Muhammad Akhlaq (Kamoki), Muhammad Ghazi Ghori (Karachi), Muhammad Riazullah (Peshawar), Noman Ali (Hyderabad), Qasim Akram (Lahore), Sameen Gul (Jamrud), Sarfaraz Ahmed (Karachi), Sahibzada Farhan (Peshawar), Sufiyan Moqim (Kotli), Umar Amin (Rawalpindi) and Usman Qadir (Lahore)

Rizwan’s Wolves: Home Advantage or False Hope?

Mohammad Rizwan, the ever-optimistic captain, is set to lead his side Wolves at their home ground in Faisalabad (Faisalabad Wolves, remember anyone?), where local support is said to be crucial. Perhaps that local support will fill the void left by any real progress at the national level. Rizwan’s Wolves, with Misbah-ul-Haq as their mentor, blend youth and experience like every other team, offering little to differentiate them in a tournament that recycles more than just strategies.

Rizwan’s comment on the “dynamic mix of players” in this year’s competition rings hollow. Isn’t that the bare minimum expected from a tournament of this scale? His hopes for home crowd energy to fuel success feel like a stretch—especially when the stakes seem more performative than practical.

Wolves squad (to be trimmed to 15 on 10 September): Mohammad Rizwan (captain, Peshawar), Fakhar Zaman (Abbottabad), Abdul Samad (Faisalabad), Akif Javed (FATA), Ali Usman (Multan), Bilawal Bhatti (Muridke), Haseebullah (Pishin), Iftikhar Ahmed (Peshawar), Kamran Ghulam (Peshawar), Mohammad Faizan (Faisalabad), Mohammad Imran Jnr (Peshawar), Mohammad Sarwar Afridi (FATA), Muhammad Imran (Khanewal), Naseem Shah (Lahore), Nisar Ahmed (Lahore), Salman Ali Agha (Lahore), Shahnawaz Dahani (Larkana), Zahid Mehmood (Dadu) and Zain Abbas (Multan)

Shadab Khan’s Panthers: A Sentimental Return or Another Familiar Script?

Shadab Khan returns to Faisalabad, where his List-A career began eight years ago in Pakistan Cup 2016, now as captain of the Panthers. While there’s a certain nostalgia in his homecoming, it’s hard to overlook that this is yet another predictable storyline in a tournament built more on sentiment than substance. Mentored by Saqlain Mushtaq, a cricket legend and the father-in-law of the team’s captain, Shadab’s team might look good on paper, but as with every other squad, the real question is whether any of this will matter in Pakistan’s larger cricketing struggles.

Shadab stressed the importance of momentum for upcoming ODIs, but one can’t help but wonder if this tournament will truly serve as a preparation ground—or just another case of going through the motions before facing the real challenges ahead.

Panthers squad (to be trimmed to 15 on 10 September): Shadab Khan (captain, Islamabad), Abdul Wahid Bangalzai (Quetta), Ahmed Bashir (Lahore), Ali Asfand (Faisalabad), Ali Raza (Sheikhupura), Amad Butt (Sialkot), Arafat Minhas (Multan), Azan Awais (Sialkot), Haider Ali (Attock), Mohammad Hasnain (Hyderabad), Mohammad Umar (Karachi), Mohammad Zeeshan (Faisalabad), Mubasir Khan (Rawalpindi), Rehan Afridi (Khyber), Rizwan Mehmood (Hyderabad), Saim Ayub (Karachi), Umar Siddiq (Lahore), Usama Mir (Sialkot), Usman Khan (Karachi) and Usman Salahuddin (Lahore)

Shaheen Afridi’s Lions: Young Guns or Token Optimism?

Shaheen Shah Afridi leads a Lions side that’s supposedly brimming with “young talent,” though in reality, this claim is made for every team in the tournament. The Lions face the Stallions in a high-octane day-night fixture on September 13, with the promise of excitement. But isn’t that the expectation for any competitive match? Afridi, Pakistan’s fast-bowling star, might be able to strike fear into opposition batters, but whether that translates into broader success remains to be seen – because lately the flair and fear of Shaheen has been a story of a bygone era. May be the mentorship of Waqar Younis can help him regain that X factor.

Shaheen’s talk of not just winning games but building a competitive team rings familiar. We’ve heard such aspirations before—whether they materialize or not is a different story altogether.

Lions Squad (to be trimmed to 15 on 10 September): Shaheen Shah Afridi (captain, Peshawar), Abdullah Shafique (Sialkot), Aamir Jamal (Islamabad), Aamer Yamin (Multan), Faisal Akram (Multan), Hassan Nawaz (Islamabad), Hunain Shah (Lahore), Imam-ul-Haq (Lahore), Imran Butt (Lahore), Khushdil Shah (Bannu), Mohammad Asghar (Karachi), Muhammad Irfan Khan (Mianwali), Mohammad Taha (Karachi), Omair Bin Yousuf (Karachi), Rohail Nazir (Islamabad), Shahab Khan (Mardan), Sharoon Siraj (Sahiwal), Sirajuddin (Bajaur) and Waqar Hussain (Okara)

Haris’ Stallions: Star Power or Familiar Faces?

Mohammad Haris leads the Stallions, a team that comes with the weight of domestic cricket history and the star power of names like Shoaib Malik as a mentor. Yet, despite Haris’ assurances that they will “entertain the crowds and television audiences,” one wonders how much of this is just a rehash of the same formula. Big names, big promises, but will it truly matter in a tournament where results seem more ceremonial than transformative? The Stallions’ opener against Shaheen Afridi’s Lions on September 13 promises a spectacle—but whether it delivers anything meaningful is another matter.

What’s Really at Stake?

While the tournament boasts an opportunity to showcase emerging talent and give seasoned players a platform, one can’t help but wonder if it’s simply window dressing for deeper systemic issues. Yes, winning the Champions One Day Cup might give teams a morale boost, but the stakes for Pakistan cricket are much higher. With international performances hitting rock bottom and the structural deficiencies of the sport still glaringly obvious, the question is: will this tournament actually move the needle?

What’s truly at stake here is more than just a trophy. The entire domestic cricket structure, beginning with this One Day Cup, needs to provide a pathway to real development or risk being a mere vanity exercise. Can this tournament foster real change, or is it just part of a larger theatrical display to distract from Pakistan cricket’s deeper failings?

Event schedule: